Veritas/Malleus/Keening mana consumption

If you want to know the community’s opinion about a topic, make a poll here.

Moderator: Game Masters

Locked

Boost the mana consumption?

Yes
33
73%
No
12
27%
 
Total votes: 45

User avatar
Darian Darkmind
Posts: 2568
Joined: Thu Nov 27, 2008 3:58 pm

Re: Veritas/Malleus/Keening mana consumption

Post by Darian Darkmind »

Raphael de Vitus wrote:Imo just leave everything how it is, its been this way for years and hasn't made the Veritas casters any more powerful. Since my time at pang i've always saw Tekstone win the majority of fights due to their Great teamwork so nerfing these rites would make them the strongest by far because they've been without a good pvp rite for like 8 years and had to deal with it.
1. Veritas casters have always been more powerful than those without veritas
2. Tekstone wins with teamwork? Correct. However, teamwork is about skills and skills are something you can learn as well. Veritas on the other hand is something that you either have or don't have.
3. Yes, we've been without veritas since day one and we've learned to deal with it. We've learned to deal with it by trying to play as a team. So, without veritas you too would soon learn to rely more on teamwork and skills. The only reason why our teamwork is so "great" is because of our years of learning from our mistakes and DEATHS.
Demian wrote:This is making veritas and malleus/keening pretty much useless. And I still think this is way too early for this before some things are really looked at first -> Sacrifice and kill. I don't see any point to be involved in a battle with necros if this nerf happens. But the staff just conveniently keeps avoiding that subject.
Kill and Sacrifice are a different thing. Also, why would this nerf make it harder? If you rush in and cast veritas, the necromancer runs. He will run no matter if you can spam it or just cast one. If you could still cast 2-3 malleus, you can still take the necromancer down. This changes absolutely nothing when fighting against necromancers.
Demian wrote:Shouldn't forget that's pretty much what makes priests, rites. Without malleus and veritas priests become weak babas/knights. Where's the balance in that?
I guess Tekstone priests aren't priests then? At least not before the keening boost? If priests become "as weak as" a well trained barbarian or knight then I say HELL YES. Where's the balance in that you ask? You answered your question yourself: Being equal with others is what balance is all about.
Maximilian Lhoth wrote:For I play a heightened Law monk, I selfishly vote no, since this would render me close to useless except as a full support.
How does that make you any less useful than a Imperial, Nature or Tekstone monk? It doesn't. It makes it balanced.
Edward Sinclair wrote:If the idea is to stop people from spamming macros/veritashi/malleustypical, wouldn't it be better to have a longer timer? So from 7 seconds delay casting veritas, you can have a 40, 50, heck even 60 second timer between every veritas cast? That way, with or without the "OP auras" that Laws and Imps are accused of having (despite Nature having their own kind of "aura" (notice the quotation marks?), greater mana regens, everyone uses their veritas sparingly.
A 60 second cooldown would do the trick as well, yeah. I don't know which one is better though. With high mana consumption there's still room for team-play and well timed veritas in order to be able to cast more of them. With the longer cooldown, you might not run out of mana, but do you really need mana if you can't spam them?
Glarundis wrote:my suggestions are to increase veritas to 40 mana and keening/malleus to 50 mana. people will use them, but a tad less. we can adjust further from there, but this is better than nothing.
It is obvious your opinion is biased. Both rituals are ridiculously powerful. Veritas is "everything in one package" where as keening and malleus are deadly with good team-work. Nerfing only malleus/keening while leaving veritas pretty much untouched, does nothing but remove Tekstone's only weapon against veritas spam. It HAS to be both nerfed.

Off topic;
This topic is funny. All Tekstone members are ready to nerf the rituals, even when it means our own OP keening gets nerfed as well. We are ready to do so because it makes PvP fun. Law on the other hand is trying to defend and hold on to their OP tomes by any means necessary. Yet, people always say Tekstone is biased, selfish and bunch of whiners? It doesn't take a genious to see which side of the players are actually selfish, biased and whiners.
User avatar
Vaux27
Posts: 3629
Joined: Mon Feb 14, 2011 5:54 am

Re: Veritas/Malleus/Keening mana consumption

Post by Vaux27 »

Here is what increasing Veritas mana consumption does to Imperial.

- Makes our only offensive rite useless
- Makes our newly acquired Mana Vault useless
- Makes our only offensive PvM rite useless


This is a hard no from Imperial unless changes come to the tome, big ones.

Here is the deal, we already have a weak tome with Veritas being our main spammed rite. Making it harder to cast would only make us worse tactically. The only way I could see this happening from my point of view is the following:

- Monks would deserve 100 Meditation(As it's Law Monks who keep this from happening due to Malleus/Veritas spam)

- Imperial would need a new offensive rite in place of guards/Esuna's curse. Rendering our only rite useless unless coupled with a rite that consumes less mana like Malleus/Keening.


This is an extreme no in our case.
Last edited by Vaux27 on Tue Nov 13, 2012 8:53 pm, edited 2 times in total.
632-140-419
Cruxis Bane
Posts: 1097
Joined: Tue Jul 10, 2012 8:59 am
Contact:

Re: Veritas/Malleus/Keening mana consumption

Post by Cruxis Bane »

Aye as much as I hate malleus i would rather leave them as they.
User avatar
Johnny Walac
Posts: 4503
Joined: Mon Nov 17, 2008 3:05 pm
Location: Sweden

Re: Veritas/Malleus/Keening mana consumption

Post by Johnny Walac »

Why not Global Veritas? Then we don't need to nerf.
Johnny Walac wrote:
Boris wrote:Keening/Malleus is as OP as Veritas.

They're both over the top considering their mana consumption.

- Boris
Then delete them from the tome and make Veritas global. Then all religions can decide how Veritas should be, PvP and PvM wise.
Image
Order of Nature - Telborea- The Britannian Trade Union - ICQ: 434212709
PvP Video 1
PvP Video 2
Cruxis Bane
Posts: 1097
Joined: Tue Jul 10, 2012 8:59 am
Contact:

Re: Veritas/Malleus/Keening mana consumption

Post by Cruxis Bane »

Ive said if you all want that go for it in my view, I just see you all missing keening after a little bit as it is alot better for pvp. Main reason I was against it before was for PVM as you all already quickly go through all the dungeons and what not.
User avatar
Johnny Walac
Posts: 4503
Joined: Mon Nov 17, 2008 3:05 pm
Location: Sweden

Re: Veritas/Malleus/Keening mana consumption

Post by Johnny Walac »

Malleus and Keening is to OP. Thats why I want it removed.
Image
Order of Nature - Telborea- The Britannian Trade Union - ICQ: 434212709
PvP Video 1
PvP Video 2
User avatar
Vaux27
Posts: 3629
Joined: Mon Feb 14, 2011 5:54 am

Re: Veritas/Malleus/Keening mana consumption

Post by Vaux27 »

Global Veritas is fine and fair, but from my point of view and taking up for Imperial, that does nothing for us. That once again makes us weak in the long run, and changes would have to occur.

I know it's not all about Imp here, but I'm giving our perspective. As every major change also has a consequence for us, especially our only offensive rite.

I agree, Malleus and Keening do need to be removed. That could fix this all as well.
632-140-419
User avatar
Johnny Walac
Posts: 4503
Joined: Mon Nov 17, 2008 3:05 pm
Location: Sweden

Re: Veritas/Malleus/Keening mana consumption

Post by Johnny Walac »

Vaux27 wrote:Global Veritas is fine and fair, but from my point of view and taking up for Imperial, that does nothing for us. That once again makes us weak in the long run, and changes would have to occur.

I know it's not all about Imp here, but I'm giving our perspective. As every major change also has a consequence for us, especially our only offensive rite.

I agree, Malleus and Keening do need to be removed. That could fix this all as well.
Global veritas means Keening and Malleus is removed. Then all have Veritas + Aura (Mana vault)

Law have Solitude and Guards on their land
Imperial have Solitude and Guards on their Land.
Nature have Swarm.
Tekstone have Swarm.

We all have different RP rites that makes the religions unique.
Image
Order of Nature - Telborea- The Britannian Trade Union - ICQ: 434212709
PvP Video 1
PvP Video 2
Cruxis Bane
Posts: 1097
Joined: Tue Jul 10, 2012 8:59 am
Contact:

Re: Veritas/Malleus/Keening mana consumption

Post by Cruxis Bane »

What would replace laws malleus?
Image
User avatar
Johnny Walac
Posts: 4503
Joined: Mon Nov 17, 2008 3:05 pm
Location: Sweden

Re: Veritas/Malleus/Keening mana consumption

Post by Johnny Walac »

Cruxis Bane wrote:What would replace laws malleus?
They surely dont need more PvP/PvM rites. Another RP rite.
Image
Order of Nature - Telborea- The Britannian Trade Union - ICQ: 434212709
PvP Video 1
PvP Video 2
Locked